The Hidden Costs of California's New Security Deposit Law

Anthony A. Luna • June 6, 2024

What Landlords and Tenants Need to Know

The Noble Intent of AB 12


California's AB 12 is a legislative response to the housing affordability crisis, a bold step by the state to ease the burden of moving costs for renters. By capping security deposits, the law aims to lower the upfront financial barriers that many individuals and families face when seeking housing. This initiative is part of a broader effort to make California's notoriously expensive rental market more accessible to a wider demographic, including lower-income families, young professionals, and others who find the high costs of entry prohibitive.


However, the implications of such well-intentioned legislation are multifaceted. While aiming to reduce financial strain on renters, AB 12 may also inadvertently impact landlords' ability to manage risks associated with new tenancies. Historically, security deposits have offered a financial buffer for property owners, covering potential damages or unpaid rents. The new cap challenges landlords to find alternative methods for safeguarding their investments without relying heavily on these deposits.

The balance between making housing more affordable and ensuring that landlords can adequately protect their properties is delicate. The success of AB 12 hinges on its execution and the collective adaptation of landlords and tenants to the changing landscape. As we move towards its implementation, the dialogue between all stakeholders remains crucial to mitigating unintended consequences and leveraging the law's potential benefits.


The Financial Quagmire for Landlords


Landlords, particularly those managing smaller properties or operating on thin margins, are navigating a complex new reality with the introduction of AB 12. The reduced financial security that comes with capped security deposits means that landlords must reassess their risk management strategies. Traditional cushions against property damage or rental arrears are diminished, prompting a need for innovative approaches to tenant screening and property maintenance.


This financial strain comes at a time when many property owners are already facing challenges such as rising insurance premiums, property taxes, and maintenance costs. The cap on deposits adds another layer of financial uncertainty. Landlords are now tasked with striking a balance: they must find ways to minimize risk while adhering to the law and maintaining fair treatment of potential and current tenants. This could mean investing more in background and credit checks, which also incurs additional costs and administrative burdens.


The realignment of financial strategies to accommodate AB 12 requires careful consideration and, potentially, the adoption of new technologies or services that help mitigate risk. Landlords might explore enhanced tenant vetting services, insurance products tailored to rental properties, or more rigorous maintenance schedules to prevent costly damages. These adaptations, while necessary, represent an ongoing financial and operational challenge for property owners across California.


The Catch-22 for Tenants


On the surface, AB 12 appears as an unequivocal win for tenants — a legislative measure designed to make housing more accessible by reducing upfront costs. However, the law's ripple effects could introduce new challenges for those it aims to help. The restriction on security deposits may lead landlords to tighten their tenant selection criteria, potentially disadvantaging individuals with less-than-stellar rental histories or lower credit scores. The heightened risk landlords face might translate into more stringent requirements, making it harder for some prospective tenants to find housing.


This situation presents a Catch-22: the very people who stand to benefit most from lower moving costs could find themselves increasingly excluded from the rental market. Landlords, in an effort to mitigate the financial risks posed by the cap on security deposits, may prioritize applicants with higher incomes or more robust rental histories, leaving financially vulnerable individuals with fewer options. Moreover, the potential increase in application denials could exacerbate issues of housing accessibility and affordability, undermining the law's intended effects.


To navigate this new landscape, potential tenants may need to take proactive steps to bolster their applications. This could include building a stronger rental history, improving credit scores, or even offering references from previous landlords. For the rental market to remain accessible in the wake of AB 12, both tenants and landlords will need to adapt to these evolving dynamics, seeking common ground that allows for risk mitigation while preserving housing opportunities.


The Domino Effect on the Real Estate Market


The broader implications of AB 12 on California's real estate market cannot be overlooked. The law might deter individual investors and small property owners from entering or remaining in the rental market, fearing increased financial risk without the traditional safety net of security deposits. A possible outcome is the consolidation of rental properties under large corporate ownership, which could have significant implications for market dynamics, housing quality, and tenant relationships.


Corporate entities, with their deeper financial reserves, are better positioned to absorb the risks associated with capped security deposits. While this could lead to a more professionally managed rental stock, it may also result in a market that's less responsive to local housing needs and community concerns. The personal touch and flexibility often found in dealings with smaller landlords could diminish, potentially altering the character of rental communities.


Furthermore, AB 12's impact on investment patterns could influence housing supply, affecting affordability and choice for tenants. A shift towards larger, corporate-owned rental properties might accelerate trends such as the commodification of housing and a focus on high-end developments, further challenging the law's goal of enhancing accessibility. The need for innovative solutions to these market shifts is evident. Policymakers, investors, and community stakeholders must collaborate to ensure that the rental market remains vibrant, diverse, and accessible in the face of these legislative changes.


A Call for Balance and Dialogue


As California embarks on this experiment with AB 12, the importance of ongoing dialogue among landlords, tenants, policymakers, and real estate professionals cannot be overstated. The law's success will depend on the collective ability of these stakeholders to navigate its implications thoughtfully and collaboratively. Finding a balance that protects the interests of both landlords and tenants, while advancing broader housing affordability goals, is crucial.


Strategies such as enhancing tenant education, exploring alternative financial guarantees for landlords, and fostering innovations in property management can help mitigate some of the challenges posed by AB 12. Additionally, monitoring the law's impact and being open to adjustments based on real-world experiences will be essential to ensuring it achieves its intended outcomes without unintended negative consequences.


Ultimately, AB 12 represents a significant step towards reimagining the relationship between landlords and tenants in California's dynamic housing market. Its implementation offers an opportunity to address longstanding barriers to housing accessibility, but it also serves as a reminder of the complex interplay between legislation, market forces, and community needs. By working together, stakeholders can navigate these complexities, laying the groundwork for a more equitable and resilient rental market.is default text and start typing your own or paste your own from a different source.

Security Deposit Calculator

Security Deposit Calculator

This tool helps landlords calculate the maximum security deposit they can charge their tenants in California, based on AB 12 guidelines. Simply enter the details about your property and click "Calculate Maximum Deposit" to see the results.

Disclaimer: This calculator is provided as a first step to understanding security deposits in California based on AB 12 guidelines. It is intended for informational purposes only and should not be considered legal or professional advice. Landlords should consult with their professional property manager or attorney to confirm the accuracy of the calculated amounts before proceeding. Legislation and guidelines may change, so it's important to stay informed about the latest requirements.

Let's elevate the industry together—share this blog with fellow investors.

A property owner studying a detailed roadmap as a guide.
By Anthony A. Luna January 7, 2025
Discover how property owners and investors can turn the 2025 property management regulations into opportunities for growth, tenant retention, and long-term success. Learn key updates and actionable strategies today.
A close-up of a credit card fee form, symbolizing transparency
By Anthony A. Luna December 5, 2024
Learn how California's AB 2493 improves transparency in rental application fees. Discover what landlords need to do to comply and enhance trust with applicants.
A service member in uniform saluting, symbolizing the protections and fee limits
By Anthony A. Luna December 4, 2024
Discover how California's SB 611 protects service members by limiting rental fees and enhancing compliance with the Servicemembers Civil Relief Act (SCRA). Learn your rights and responsibilities.
A property manager reviewing a paper copy of a credit report
By Anthony A. Luna December 3, 2024
Learn how California's AB 2747 requires landlords to offer rent payment reporting to credit bureaus. Discover the benefits, compliance steps, and impact on property management.
Show More

More about Coastline Equity

  • Property Management Services

    Skyscraper

    Our team will handle all your property needs, offering specialized services such as in-depth inspections, liability management, staff recruitment and training, and round-the-clock maintenance—expert support tailored to the unique requirements of your real estate assets.

    Learn More
  • About Us

    Look at the future of property management

    Our dedicated team transforms property management challenges into opportunities. From tenant management to streamlined rent collection and proactive maintenance. 

    Learn More
  • Property Management Excellence

    Anthony A Luna CEO

    As a contributing author for Forbes, Anthony A. Luna brings a wealth of expertise and knowledge in the property management industry, real estate sector, and entrepreneurship, providing insights and thought-provoking analysis on a range of topics including property management, industry innovation, and leadership.


    Anthony has established himself as a leading voice in the business community. Through his contributions to Forbes, Anthony is set to publish his first book, "Property Management Excellence" in April 2025 with Forbes Books.

    Learn More
  • Insights

    Discover property management

    Learn more about Coastline Equity's property management practices & processes and how we support our clients with education and a growth mindset.


    Coastline Equity Property Management is your partner as you continue to learn and grow.

    Learn More

News & Updates

By John David Sarmiento April 11, 2025
Setting the right rent isn’t just about earning income — it’s about finding the balance between maximizing cash flow and keeping your property consistently occupied. So, what exactly is fair rent for your property? Whether you're renting out a single-family home, an apartment, or a unit in a multi-family building, finding a fair rental price starts with a thoughtful look at your property, your market, and what today’s renters are willing to pay. Start with Comparable Rentals The best way to find a fair rent is to research comparable rentals in your area. Look for listings similar in: Square footage Number of bedrooms and bathrooms Neighborhood Condition and amenities Platforms like Zillow, Apartments.com, or Rent.com are a great place to browse rental listings and compare active prices. If you’re seeing similar units listed at a higher rate than yours — and they're still on the market weeks later — that could be a sign they’re overpriced. Units that rent fast tell you what renters are actually willing to pay. Real Example: Pricing a 2-Bedroom in Long Beach Let’s say you own a 2-bedroom, 1-bath apartment in Long Beach with around 900 square feet. You check listings and find similar properties renting for $2,300 to $2,500. Zillow shows a rent zestimate of $2,400 — a decent starting point, but not the full picture. After looking at how long listings have stayed active and talking to a local property manager , you find out that well-maintained units with in-unit laundry and parking are consistently getting rented at $2,350. You price your unit accordingly, giving yourself a competitive edge while still earning market value. Avoid Relying on Algorithms Alone Automated pricing tools like the rent zestimate are useful for a ballpark figure, but they often miss local demand shifts, recent upgrades, or what renters truly value in your neighborhood. Use them as one data point — not your final decision-maker. Other Factors That Influence Fair Rent Your final rent amount should reflect more than just comps. Consider: The property’s condition: Have you renovated or upgraded appliances recently? Extras included: Are you covering any utilities? Is there secure parking or outdoor space? Seasonality: Rental demand can vary throughout the year. Your goals: Are you focused on fast occupancy or maximizing revenue? Professional support: A trusted rental manager or property manager can offer current insights based on tenant activity, vacancy rates, and pricing trends.  How Property Managers Help You Set the Right Price If you're unsure what to charge, a local property manager can evaluate your unit, compare it to others in your area, and recommend a pricing strategy that balances demand and return. They also help adjust your price over time as rental rates shift, and they’ll guide you in attracting and retaining quality tenants who value both the price and the property. Final Thoughts So, what is fair rent for your property? It’s the price that matches what your unit offers, reflects the current market, and appeals to qualified renters. It’s not necessarily the highest number possible — it’s the one that helps you rent quickly, reduce turnover, and maintain steady income. With a little research, a realistic view of your property’s features, and guidance from local experts, you’ll be well-positioned to price your rental right — and keep it occupied with great tenants.
By John David Sarmiento April 10, 2025
One of the most delicate parts of owning a rental property is figuring out how to increase the rent without driving away good tenants. While you want to stay competitive with market rates , it’s equally important to maintain stable occupancy and avoid costly turnovers. The good news? With the right strategy and timing, raising rent doesn’t have to come at the cost of your tenant relationships. 1. Know Your Local Market Rates Before you decide to raise the rent , research similar properties in your area to understand current rent prices . If you're significantly below market value, a reasonable increase is often accepted — especially by tenants who like where they live. Even if you're close to market rate, a small adjustment can still make sense if you’re offering added value like upgraded amenities, responsive maintenance, or flexible lease terms. 2. Time It Around Lease Renewals The best time to increase the rental rate is when a tenant is renewing the lease . This gives them the chance to consider the new rate and evaluate their options — all while avoiding the hassle and cost of moving. Be sure to send a formal rent increase notice with enough lead time, typically 30 to 60 days in advance, depending on local regulations. 3. Communicate the “Why” Clearly When increasing rent, communication is everything. Let your tenants know the reasons behind the increase: Rising property taxes or insurance Increases in maintenance or utility costs Alignment with market rates Planned improvements to the unit or building Even if they don’t love the change, most tenants are more receptive when they feel respected and informed. 4. Offer Options and Flexibility If you’re working with long-term tenants you’d like to keep, consider offering choices to soften the increase: Extend the lease at the current rate for a few more months Offer a discounted rate for early renewal Split the increase over two payments instead of one lump sum This approach shows that you're not just looking to raise the rent , but to build a fair and lasting relationship. 5. Lean on Your Property Manager (If You Have One) Experienced property managers can provide insight into local rent prices , craft professional communications, and help navigate lease renewals in a way that keeps tenants happy while protecting your bottom line. They can also deliver rent increase notices and handle pushback more objectively. If you manage your property on your own, consider consulting a manager or local expert before finalizing your approach. Final Thoughts Increasing the rental rate is a normal part of owning a rental property , but it should always be done with care and intention. When you base your decisions on market research, communicate transparently, and give tenants room to respond, you’re more likely to keep good renters in place — even at a higher price point.  Want help reviewing your current lease structure or market position before you raise the rent? We’re here to support you.
By John David Sarmiento April 9, 2025
Finding the right tenant is one of the most important things you’ll do as a property owner. The right renter can mean steady income, fewer problems, and long-term stability — while the wrong one can lead to missed rent, damage, or legal headaches. So how do you actually find great tenants for your rental property? Here's a clear, step-by-step approach that works — whether you're a new landlord or a seasoned investor. 1. Write a Clear, Honest Rental Listing Start by crafting a listing that highlights what makes your property attractive, but also sets clear expectations. Good property descriptions should include: Rental price and lease length Number of bedrooms and bathrooms Location and amenities Any restrictions (pets, smoking, etc.) Post your listing on multiple rental listing sites — but don’t underestimate the power of rent signs in front of the property, especially if it's in a high-traffic area. 2. Market Where Your Ideal Tenants Are To reach more prospective tenants , take your marketing beyond listing sites. Post your property on social media , community groups, and even local forums. Word of mouth can also be powerful — let friends, colleagues, and neighbors know the unit is available. Make sure your contact information is easy to find and consistent across platforms. You want prospective renters to reach you quickly when interest is high. 3. Use a Standard Rental Application When potential tenants reach out, have a standard rental application ready to go. This not only helps you stay organized, but ensures you’re collecting all the info you’ll need for the next step — tenant screenings . A good application should request: Full name and contact details Employment and income information References and previous landlord contacts Authorization for a background check and credit score pull 4. Screen Tenants Thoroughly (and Legally) One of the most critical steps in finding good tenants is how you screen tenants . Don’t skip this part — it’s where most rental issues can be avoided. Effective tenant screenings usually include: Background check (criminal history, eviction records) Credit score and payment history Verification of employment and income Reference checks with their previous landlord Always follow housing laws when screening applicants. Be consistent, fair, and avoid any language or decisions that could be considered discriminatory under the Fair Housing Act. 5. Collect a Security Deposit and Finalize the Lease Once you’ve found a great tenant , collect a security deposit (within the limits set by your state), and have both parties sign a clear, legally binding lease agreement . Your lease should detail rent amounts, due dates, responsibilities, and procedures for repairs or disputes. If you're not sure how to draft one, consult with a landlord or property manager familiar with local rental laws. Final Thoughts Finding the right tenant takes more than just putting up a listing — it takes a clear strategy, legal awareness, and the ability to evaluate prospective tenants fairly and confidently. The effort you put in now saves time, money, and stress later.  If you're unsure or simply want to ensure a smooth process, working with a professional property management company can make tenant placement and lease compliance much easier.
More Posts

Property Management Made Easy


Los Angeles

1411 W. 190th St.,
Suite 225

Los Angeles, CA 90248

Temecula

41743 Enterprise Circle N.,
Suite 207

Temecula, CA 92590